Page MenuHome GnuPG

IDEA page should mention incompatibility of idea.c with gpg2
Closed, ResolvedPublic

Description

The page http://www.gnupg.org/faq/why-not-idea.en.html links to the idea.c
library. This library is not compatible with gpg2. This should be mentioned on
the webpage. In addition, a sentence like "Users who are dependend on using IDEA
are advised to use a GPG 1.x version instead of GPG2." should be added.

Event Timeline

GnUPG 2 actually supports IDEA via Libgcrypt and GnuPG also includes IDEA
meanwhile. Thus the whole idea thing does not make anymore sense.

We may eventually update that web page.

Yes, please add your information to the webpage, incl. the exact version numbers
and their dependency/relation to IDEA/idea.c/...

For usability reasons, the "load extension" option could check for idea.c
parameter and reject this explicitly in those versions that don't need/support
this anymore. This might be an option in contrast to change all old forum
entries around in the internet discussing this topic.... ;-)
But this would be another bug report, I guess.

Thanks.

--load-extension is a dummy function. It does not do anything.

werner claimed this task.

The web page has been updated.