When deleting an attachment it seems gone, but is in fact replaced with a numbered copy of the same file, as visible by clicking on the mail again. I accept that removing attachments will break the signature, but other than that it should be possible, or there should be a warning.
Description
Description
Details
Details
- Version
- Gpg4win 3.1.0
Revisions and Commits
Revisions and Commits
| rO GpgOL | |||
| rOd13de350caa2 Show warning if attachment of crypt mail removed | |||
| rOd3a220f060cd Fix early deletion of temporary attachments | |||
| Status | Assigned | Task | ||
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Resolved | • aheinecke | T3742 Gpg4win 3.1.0 | ||
| Resolved | • aheinecke | T3886 attachments can't be removed |
Event Timeline
Comment Actions
In fact, renumbering of attachments happens also by just viewing them repeatedly. This likely causes multiple copies somewhere, reducing disk space.
Also, renumbering is not done correctly in a case where there is multiple dots in the file name, like a date. See attached example:
Comment Actions
I'll go for a warning / error for now and see if I can fix the renumbering.
We can't really remove attachments. Maybe we could persistently hide them but that would probably defeat the purpose of removing them (making the mail smaller).
- For Signed - Not encrypted mails we could offer to remove the signature when removing an attachment.
- For Encrypted Mails there is a long standing feature request to allow "permanent decryption" then you could permanently decrypt and remove an attachment. Anything else for encrypted Mails like "re encrypting the message without the attachment" is complex and is currently far away.
Normal Prio as this is not a regression and might not make it into a 3.1.0 release.
Comment Actions
When an attachment of a crypto mail is removed it now leads to a warning.
I also think that I have fixed the cause for the renumbering issue.
Comment Actions
I've opened T3895 for a permanent decryption / permanent removal of attachments. Maybe something for 3.2.0 ;-)