Page MenuHome GnuPG

needs discussionPolicy
ActivePublic

Members

  • This project does not have any members.
  • View All

Watchers

  • This project does not have any watchers.
  • View All

Details

Description

Needs to be discussed…

Recent Activity

Fri, Feb 27

ebo added a project to T5707: Kleopatra: Use windows registry additionally to config files: needs discussion.

@werner said the reading order should be like on the page https://gnupg.com/vsd/kleopatra-settings.html:

Fri, Feb 27, 3:50 PM · needs discussion, gpd5x, gpg4win, kleopatra

Thu, Feb 26

hej added a comment to T7502: Kleopatra: Import secret key dialog improvement.

I tend to agree with keeping it short and close to the wording we use for normal public key imports.

Thu, Feb 26, 1:08 PM · vsd34, gpd5x, kleopatra

Tue, Feb 24

ebo added a comment to T7502: Kleopatra: Import secret key dialog improvement.

How about "Certification includes that you check the fingerprint against a trusted source."? "Means" seems wrong to me. @hej, please comment

Tue, Feb 24, 1:42 PM · vsd34, gpd5x, kleopatra
ebo added a comment to T8077: Kleopatra: Bold appearance for qualified signatures might be confusing for public and non-signing keys.

ok, lets do this. I'll update the description

Tue, Feb 24, 12:45 PM · S/MIME, vsd34, gpd5x, kleopatra
timegrid added a comment to T8077: Kleopatra: Bold appearance for qualified signatures might be confusing for public and non-signing keys.

I'm fine with just dropping it.

Tue, Feb 24, 12:25 PM · S/MIME, vsd34, gpd5x, kleopatra
ikloecker added a comment to T7502: Kleopatra: Import secret key dialog improvement.

I'm okay with omitting the list of suggestions for shared secret keys. The person distributing the key should have told the recipients how to import and certify them properly.

Tue, Feb 24, 9:05 AM · vsd34, gpd5x, kleopatra

Mon, Feb 23

ebo added a comment to T7502: Kleopatra: Import secret key dialog improvement.

How about changing the text after sentence two simply to:

Mon, Feb 23, 4:08 PM · vsd34, gpd5x, kleopatra
ebo added a comment to T8077: Kleopatra: Bold appearance for qualified signatures might be confusing for public and non-signing keys.

Do we agree to drop bolt font for QES certificates?
Will we change this for VSD 3.4?

Mon, Feb 23, 1:50 PM · S/MIME, vsd34, gpd5x, kleopatra

Fri, Feb 6

ebo added a project to T7502: Kleopatra: Import secret key dialog improvement: needs discussion.
Fri, Feb 6, 2:27 PM · vsd34, gpd5x, kleopatra
ebo triaged T8059: Gpg4win: Change bug report address to a Gpg4win-specific address as Normal priority.
Fri, Feb 6, 10:13 AM · needs discussion, gpd5x, kleopatra, gpg4win

Tue, Feb 3

timegrid added a comment to T8077: Kleopatra: Bold appearance for qualified signatures might be confusing for public and non-signing keys.

The display in Okular is independent from Kleopatra, so dropping it in Kleopatra should be fine.
If a QES certificate is available, Okular should highlight and add a filter for them (which is currently not working, see T6632: Okular: Highlight / preselect "nonRepudiation" certificates for qualified signatures)

Tue, Feb 3, 1:34 PM · S/MIME, vsd34, gpd5x, kleopatra
ebo added a comment to T8077: Kleopatra: Bold appearance for qualified signatures might be confusing for public and non-signing keys.

I currently have a slight preference to drop bold and go with normal font. Werner would be ok with that, too.

Tue, Feb 3, 1:17 PM · S/MIME, vsd34, gpd5x, kleopatra
timegrid updated subscribers of T8077: Kleopatra: Bold appearance for qualified signatures might be confusing for public and non-signing keys.

@svuorela said, QES certs shouldn't be required to be on a smartcard.

Tue, Feb 3, 12:20 PM · S/MIME, vsd34, gpd5x, kleopatra
ikloecker added a comment to T8077: Kleopatra: Bold appearance for qualified signatures might be confusing for public and non-signing keys.

Using an icon for QES certificates isn't that easy because we use an icon for smartcard certificates and any list item can have at most one icon. Moreover, QES certificates are very like stored on a smartcard (isn't that even a requirement?), i.e. an icon clash is basically guaranteed.

Tue, Feb 3, 11:49 AM · S/MIME, vsd34, gpd5x, kleopatra
timegrid added a comment to T8077: Kleopatra: Bold appearance for qualified signatures might be confusing for public and non-signing keys.

In T6632: Okular: Highlight / preselect "nonRepudiation" certificates for qualified signatures I had the impression, that some hint is useful for signing operations. Probably not so much in general.

Tue, Feb 3, 11:04 AM · S/MIME, vsd34, gpd5x, kleopatra
ebo added a comment to T8077: Kleopatra: Bold appearance for qualified signatures might be confusing for public and non-signing keys.

Highlighting QES is mostly useful for Okular, I guess.
Maybe use a symbol with a pen? That should be self-explanatory.

Tue, Feb 3, 10:44 AM · S/MIME, vsd34, gpd5x, kleopatra
ebo triaged T8077: Kleopatra: Bold appearance for qualified signatures might be confusing for public and non-signing keys as Normal priority.
Tue, Feb 3, 10:40 AM · S/MIME, vsd34, gpd5x, kleopatra
timegrid added a project to T8077: Kleopatra: Bold appearance for qualified signatures might be confusing for public and non-signing keys: needs discussion.
Tue, Feb 3, 10:30 AM · S/MIME, vsd34, gpd5x, kleopatra

Jan 23 2026

timegrid changed the status of T6612: Kleopatra can't be started from the gpg shell of the AppImage, a subtask of T6630: Platform independent starter, from Open to Testing.
Jan 23 2026, 11:31 AM · needs discussion, gpd5x, Windows, Feature Request, AppImage
timegrid edited projects for T6630: Platform independent starter, added: gpd5x, needs discussion; removed Restricted Project.
Jan 23 2026, 11:28 AM · needs discussion, gpd5x, Windows, Feature Request, AppImage

Jan 8 2026

ebo added a project to T6793: Cleanup temporary files / dirs with decrypted content: needs discussion.
Jan 8 2026, 10:58 AM · needs discussion, gpd5x, kleopatra
ebo created needs discussion.
Jan 8 2026, 10:58 AM